Hare Krishna Gurudev.
Please accept my humble and respectful obeisances.
All glories to Srila Prabhupada and all glories to you.
Gurudev, I am very confused. I don't understand what is happening in the Hare Krishna movement and where it is headed.
I know you might say, "Only Krishna knows"...
But I have questions that I need answered to calm my mind a little. Please, Gurudev, help me to clear up some of these doubts.
I begin with these questions to understand the position of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada:
Is Srila Prabhupada tri-kala-jña (knowing past, present, and future)? Is Srila Prabhupada a sakti-avesa-avatara and a nitya siddha, sent from the spiritual world by Krishna?
I understand, as I've heard, that Srila Prabhupada's books will govern humanity for millennia to come.
I accept them as they are; I love them and they fill me with pleasure. For 11 years, I've read nothing but Srila Prabhupada's books every day.
However, some devotees say that Srila Prabhupada's books contain statements that won't please materialistic society. Statements against materialists, scientists, Christians, men, women, politicians, etc., etc., etc...
But the most pressing and prevalent issue in the West today is what is known as feminism, or the demand for women's rights.
This issue affects all statements and discourses—political, religious, human, psychological, the education of children, universities, etc. etc. etc. (especially in the West). It permeates everything.
Turning to our movement of sankīrtana, of preaching, for example, in the introduction to the Bhagavad Gītā, Srila Prabhupada says: "...Whether superior or inferior, prakṛti is always under control. Prakṛti is feminine, and the Lord controls it just as the husband controls the activities of the wife..."
This idea that the husband controls the wife is not going to sit well with the society of this era (and I emphasize that this statement is in the introduction to the Bhagavad Gītā!!).
Nor will many people take kindly to many verses of the Bhagavad Gītā (for example, 9.32), of the Śrīmad Bhāgavatam (such as, for example, in the story of Urvaśī and Pururava, the sayings of Urvaśī - canto 9, chapter 14), and the dozens of commentaries where Śrīla Prabhupāda quotes Canakya Pandita and also other meanings of Śrila Prabhupāda himself; he speaks of topics that may upset some people...
So the obvious question is the same as always: Does the Hare Krsna ISKCON movement have to adapt to the "isms" and ideologies and discourses that prevail in the world (as the "Krsna West" faction of Hrdayananda das Goswami is already doing, for example), or conversely, do people "of the world" have to adapt to the "apauruseya" concepts of our books?
What is Gurudev like?
Gurudev, I'm sure I'm missing many things (I can't understand, I'm such a fool!!!). Probably because of my narrow and conditioned mind.
Thank you, Gurudev, Forgive my offenses and ignorance.
Your aspiring servant, Deva Vrata das
HpS/ASA - Hare Krsna! AgtSP. Paoho. Many points.
For example, first question:
"Is Srila Prabhupada tri-kala-jña (knowing past, present, and future)?"
Revatinandana Swami spent a lot of time with Srila Prabhupada personally. He, RnS, was head cook under hell, hell, hellish circumstances for our ISKCON camp at the Kumbhamela with Srila Prabhupada and devotees.
He asked SP about several of these controversial points.
He visited our San Francisco Temple about 1974 and at one time he commented that he told Srila Prabhupada that many of his disciples thought that he knew what they were doing at every moment.
He said that Srila Prabhupada responded:
I am not the SuperSoul.
When I need to know something about a disciple, Krsna informs me, and usually through an external means.
We, HpS/ASA might offer an illustration: Srila Prabhupada is in Mayapura and is wondering how his Temple President, Bhakta Das, is doing in San Francisco.
The next day three very nice, strong, honest B'cari disciples arrive from San Francisco to spend a few weeks in Sri Dhama Mayapura and he can have direct communication with them about San Francisco and President etc.
So, it is not some mental consciousness alone. It is practical knowledge in the foreground of spiritual life, but within the heart there is confirmation that the most sane thing is that Krsna has sent these people and I can also trust them intuitively.
Maybe Srila Prabhupada is on another level.
Maybe he is an incarnation of Satyaki?
These mental speculations which later we may be practically living are O.K. but in the foreground of spiritual life we keep practical knowledge and practical activity.
O.K.???
Past present and future all exist in the present. Only the modes of ignorance and passion make us think that things and ideas exist in some past and some future.
Material goodness is contaminated with passion and ignorance and so we even experience things in the current moment with some past and future.
In Pure Goodness we can see that some ideas, knowledge, thoughts are labeled memories and some are labeled plans. Yet, they are all thoughts: Thinking, Feeling, Willing. This is all "knowledge" on the level of Manas.
Above this is knowledge on the level of Buddhi, then Ahankara, then Spiritual Knowledge: Maha-visnu loka.
Vaikuntha loka.
Ayodhya.
Mathura.
Dvaraka.
Goloka.
Santa bhava goloka.
Dasya bhava goloka.
O.K.?
As far as I know, Srila Prabhupada has a practical knowledge of past, present and future to engage himself and us in Krsna's service up to the level of 1st, 2nd and 3rd initiation.
Are you going to take 3rd initiation?
I can give you the Mantras.
No female disciple of Srila Prabhupada has heard the Sannyasa mantras from his lips or the lips of one of his sannyasa disciples. 😆
I think that we may put impersonalism (material scientism) and voidism as even more " pressing and prevalent issue(s) in the West today" than feminism.
O.K.?
So, many more nice topics, but now the sun is at 6:00 PM (Post Meridian) here in ISKCON Houston. So we will go post a first class mail letter in the mail box to Nila Bosh with Mahaprasadam and a thank you for his donation of $100 and hospitality, on the way to the Temple for Srila Gaura kishora Das Babaji Maharaja's tiro bhava festival.
We will post some clips on the WhatsApp Anvesaka Group.
How can we improve our service?
How can we improve our communication with our Sankirtan team?
Today is ekadasi. Send all comments for the Kapi-dhvaja today or ASAP.
..................................
Hare Krsna Gurudev.
por favor acepte mis humildes y respetuosas reverencias.
Todas las glorias a Śrīla Prabhupāda y todas las glorias para usted.
Gurudev, estoy muy confundido. No entiendo lo que está pasando en el movimiento Hare Krishna y hacia adonde se dirige este.
Sé que tú quizás me dirás, "solo Krsna sabe"...
Pero me surgen preguntas que necesito responder, para apaciguar un poco mi mente.
Por favor Gurudev, ayudame a salir un poco de estas dudas.
Empiezo con estas preguntas para entender la posición de Su Divina Gracia A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
¿Śrīla Prabhupāda es tri- kala- jña (conoce pasado, presente y futuro)?
¿Śrīla Prabhupāda es un sakti-avesa-avatara, y un nitya siddha, que viene desde el mundo espiritual enviado por Krishna?
Yo entiendo, como he escuchado, que los libros de Śrīla Prabhupāda van a regir a la humanidad por lo próximos milenios.
Yo los acepto tal como están, a mi me encantan y me llenan de placer.
Hace 11 años que no leo otra cosa que los libros de Srila Prabhupada todos los días.
Mas, sin embargo, algunos devotos dicen que en los libros de Srila Prabhupada hay declaraciones que no van a agradar a la sociedad materialista.
Declaraciones contra los materialistas, los cientificos, los cristianos, los hombres, las mujeres, los políticos, etc. etc. etc...
Pero el tema más candente e imperante hoy en día en occidente, es lo que se conoce como feminismo o el reclamo de los derechos de las mujeres.
Este tema afecta todos los dichos y los dicursos, tanto políticos, religiosos, humanos, psicológicos, la educación de los niños, de la universidades, etc. etc. etc. (sobre todoen occidente). Atravieza todo.
Yendo a nuestro movimiento de sankīrtana, de prédica, por ejemplo, en la introducción del Bhagavad Gītā, Srīla Prabhupada dice:
"...Ya sea superior o inferior, prakṛti siempre se halla bajo control. Prakṛti es femenina, y el Señor la controla tal como el esposo controla las actividades de la esposa..."
Esto, de que el esposo controla a la esposa, a la sociedad de esta era no les va a caer muy bien (y enfatizo que esta declaración está en ¡¡la introducción del Bhagavad Gīta!!)
Tampoco a muchos les caeran bien muchos versos del Bhagavad Gītā (por ejemplo el 9.32), del Śrīmad Bhāgavatam (como por ejemplo en la historia de Urvaśī y Pururava los dichos de Urvasī -canto 9 capítulo 14) y las decenas de comentarios donde Śrīla Prabhupāda cita a Canakya Pandita y también otros significados de Śrila Prabhupāda él mismo habla de temas que pueden molestar a ciertas personas...
Entonces la pregunta obvia es la de siempre:
¿Tiene el movimiento Hare Krsna ISKCON que aggiornarse a los "ismos" e ideologías y discursos que imperan en el mundo (como ya está haciendo, por ejemplo, la facción "Krsna West" de Hrdayananda das Goswami) o al revés, la gente "del mundo" aggiornarse a los conceptos "apaurusheya" de nuestros libros?
¿Cómo es Gurudev?
Gurudev,
segurame muchas cosas se me están pasando por alto (no puedo entender soy un gran tonto!!!). Seguramente por mi mente estrecha y condicionada.
Gracias Gurudev,
Perdona mis ofensas e ignorancia.
Tu aspirante a sirviente
Deva Vrata das